Friday, November 30, 2012

Good riddance – SB 3442 is dead!

We have long supported the promulgation of reusable bags and containers, and we encourage people to eschew and reduce the consumption of single-use plastic items.  We've helped raise awareness of the environmental and economic impacts of plastic litter, and we've supported a great number of policies that try to address these issues head on.

Well over 100 jurisdictions across the United States, and even 11 entire nations have banned single-use plastic bags.

Naturally, certain industry interests are not pleased by these bag bans, and they do everything in their power to fight the bans we're trying to implement.  They also dig in deep with a new tactic recently.  Instead of trying to stomp out bans as they begin to sprout, they are now trying to convince lawmakers just to prohibit bans.

"Huh?  What?", you say?

Illinois Senate Bill (SB) 3442 was a prime example.  Earlier this year, SB 3442 snuck through the Illinois General Assembly as a wolf in sheep's clothing.  Disguised as a pro-environment recycling bill, SB 3442 did nothing in terms of increasing recycling efforts of plastic bags (which doesn't work anyway).  However the real bite to this bill was that it sought to preempt "home rule", and would have specifically prohibited municipalities from not only banning single-use plastic bags, but would have also prevented municipalities from implementing their own recycling programs.

Illinois residents use more than 4.8 billion single-use plastic bags every year.  The State of Illinois spends more than $9 Million annually for litter cleanup efforts.  As plastic bags comprise an inordinate percentage of the litter stream by weight, they are disproportionately responsible for those costs.  Moreover, this figure does not include any of the energy costs associated with producing single-use bags, nor does it consider any of the negative environmental, economic, and public health costs associated with single-use bag litter.

"urban tumbleweed" yesterday in Chicago.
Photo ©2012 Christopher Chin

Plastic bags are a costly, environmentally damaging, and easily preventable source of litter and pollution.  Light and aerodynamic, plastic bags are uniquely litter-prone even when properly disposed of, and pose a serious threat to the environment and wildlife in our streams, waterways, lakes, and oceans.  Plastic bags never truly disappear in these environments; even when they are no longer visible to the naked eye, plastic bags have merely photo-degraded into tiny particles that absorb toxins and contaminate our food chain and water and soil quality.  Plastic bags also make up a disproportionate share of the litter stream, harming storm water systems, increasing cleanup costs for local agencies, and eating away at taxpayer dollars.

Recycling of plastic bags, while seemingly well intentioned, would accomplish nothing.  

A similar 2006 California recycling policy failed.  Despite the creation of a statewide collection infrastructure for plastic bags, a mere THREE percent (3%) of plastic bags have been recycled.  Plastic bag recycling is neither practical nor cost effective.  The market scrap price for recycled plastic comes nowhere close to covering the costs of collecting, transporting, and handling the bags.  Nationally, the US EPA shows a 4.3% recycling rate for HDPE plastic bags and film combined

Recycling is not the answer.  Despite efforts to expand recycling programs, in other States and municipalities around the world, the recycling rate of single-use plastic bags remains around 5%.  The remainder of these bags end up in our landfills or as litter, clogging storm drain systems, and making their way to our waterways and ocean.  It is estimated that 60–80% of all marine debris, and 90% of floating debris is plastic.  Plastic lasts for hundreds of years in our environment and may never biodegrade in the ocean.  As a result, it poses a persistent threat to wildlife.  At least 267 species worldwide have been impacted by plastic in our oceans, including plastic bags. 

SB 3442 would have set a horrible precedent.  We appealed to the Governor of Illinois, Pat Quinn, to veto the bill.  I had the opportunity to meet Governor Quinn when he signed our shark fin bill (HB4119) into law, and in speaking with him, it was immediately apparent that this man wanted to do the right thing.

Since SB 3442 was marked as having fiscal impact, the Illinois General Assembly required a 3/5 vote to pass both chambers.  How much of a vote would be required to override the governor's veto?  3/5.  Yikes!  Yes, the vote was presumably already there, and the Governor was sticking his neck out for us.

SB 3442 was a controversial bill in both chambers of the General Assembly, and found support mostly as a result of its spurious language.  Just as we were able to convince inland legislators and constituents of the importance of shark conservation, we were confident we could help illuminate the true intentions of this deceptive bill.  We assured the Governor that we could provide the support necessary to sustain  his veto.

12-year old Abby Goldberg from Grayslake, Illinois started a petition to encourage the Governor to veto SB 3442, and in the end, she was able to present Governor Quinn with more than 170,000 signatures from around the world.  He graciously accepted them at a press conference, and this also helped shed more light on the issue.

On 26 August, Governor Quinn officially rejected SB 3442, much to our relief!  But remember, that 3/5 vote was still looming, and you know that the industry was going to try to rally.  Knowing that legislators generally only alter their positions for a very good reason, we had our work cut out for us.

Well, as they usually do, truth and awareness usually prevail, and we're pleased to say that SB 3442 is now officially dead!  The bill's author, Senator Terry Link (D-Lincolnshire), filed a motion to override the Governor's veto, and the Senate rejected that yesterday afternoon.

Thank you, Governor Quinn, for doing the right thing, for believing in us, and for having the political courage to follow your convictions.  Thank you, Abby for starting your petition, and for bringing your voice and so many others into the mix.  And thank YOU, all of our supporters, for your phone calls, e-mail messages, and for sharing our calls-to-action to raise awareness of this issue and provide the support necessary to make this happen.

We could not have done this without you.


  1. Our Busty Escorts Agency in Mahipalpur are wonderful in offering facilities of the unusual standard.Dating Call Girls in Dehradun These babes are too sexy in appearance and wear short outfits to capture the attention of males.Dating Call Girls in Dehradun These babes use a lot of makeup on their face and are too friendly with males.Call Girls in Agra If you are seeking the Call Girls in Ajmer right babe to offer you excellent sensuality then certainly look for these Hot Call Girls in Agra.

  2. Your article is extremely attractive and interesting, hopefully more people will know and visit your blog. 안전놀이터

  3. Its an amazing website, really enjoy your articles. Helpful and interesting too. Keep doing this in future. I will support you. 바둑이사이트

  4. She has a special place in her coronary heart for Sega and on-line poker. Players will ready to|be succesful of|have the power to} handle the shoe, maintain rating using conventional scorecards, and share within the pleasure with fellow players. After the energetic participant has referred to as 'carte' or 'non' it is the banker's flip a glance at|to take a look at} 1xbet the banker's two playing cards. When several of} players have wager, the participant who positioned the largest wager towards the banker is designated by the croupier because the energetic participant or punter. This participant makes any decisions required on behalf of the players. If you’re on the lookout for a recreation or thrilling poker match motion, look no further than The Orleans, house to one of many Vegas' hottest poker rooms!

  5. Very good news is shared in this article. It is very intresting article. I suggest you to keep publishing article like these.

  6. Goa Tour Packages Under 10000

    Goa Tour Packages Under 10000, Looking for fun activities to do from June to August? we've got you covered! Below is a list of activities that will be available during this time. Take a look and let us know if you are interested in booking any of them. And don't forget, you can avail up to 20% off on these activities. Whether you want to try water sports, explore the local culture, or go on a romantic sunset cruise, there is something here for everyone. So why wait? Book your activity today and get ready for an unforgettable experience while saving some money.

  7. Si los visitantes de El Paso quieren viajar a los diferentes lugares del mundo, entonces San Diego es una opción magnífica. Después de obtener los Vuelos Desde El Paso a San Diego, los viajeros pueden visitar el parque Balboa para montar en bicicleta o disfrutar el pícnic con sus respectivos amigos o relativos.

  8. Truly a Best Assignment Helper Agency so far. I have been looking for the best assignment service providers online and finally came across them. From the time-line to the submissions everything was up to the mark. Finally I scored the desired results and really amhapy with the services.

  9. Our skilled lawyer will provide a legal advice and represent in court, are still waiting for Bank Ruptcy Lawyer Near Me

  10. In an era of technological advancements and worldwide financial systems, wire fraud has grown to be a significant concern for both people and companies. To protect your rights and navigate the complexities of the legal system, you must retain the services of an expert Union Wire Fraud Defense Lawyer while handling wire fraud accusations in a union context. wire fraud defense lawyer


  11. Excellent Article and Very informative too. Once more thanks for sharing.
    Abogado Criminal Federal de Nueva Jersey

  12. Interesting and shocking to read this post. Keep sharing more good blogs. Fairfax Virginia DUI Lawyer

  13. Understanding the preliminary protective order in virginia? Learn about the legal steps involved and how our expert attorneys can assist you in obtaining the protection you need.


  14. Thank you for sharing such valuable information!. Use Ultraguard PPF to fortify your car's defenses against the weather. Our PPF Coating for Car creates an imperceptible barrier to protect your car's paint from stone chips, scratches, and UV rays, offering unparalleled protection. Experience peace of mind knowing that your vehicle is protected by cutting-edge technology with Ultraguard, guaranteeing long-lasting beauty and value for every ride.

  15. Coare" presents a sleek and intuitive platform for streamlined collaboration and project management. With its user-friendly interface and robust features, it enhances productivity and efficiency for teams of all sizes. However, incorporating more customization options could further tailor the platform to individual team needs. Overall, it's a promising tool for optimizing workflow and achieving project success contract dispute settlement agreement